| Ethan Hill | | Freeport | NIC-10 1st Team |
| Jack Heimer | | Freeport | NIC-10 Special Mention |
| Gannon Ruckman | | Freeport | NIC-10 Special Mention |
| Tayden Patterson | 2020 | River Ridge | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Aiden Sullivan | 2020 | West Carroll | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Max Amendt | 2021 | Lena/Winslow | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Micah Knauer | 2019 | River Ridge | NUIC West 1st Team (Unanimous), All-State |
| Braden Smargiassi | 2019 | Pearl City | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Jared Underwood | 2020 | River Ridge | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Kaden Henze | 2019 | Eastland | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Noah McGivney | 2019 | Warren/Stockton | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Zach Lieb | 2019 | Pearl City | NUIC West 1st Team |
| Drew Burkholder | 2021 | Eastland | NUIC West 2nd Team |
| Andy Wurster | 2020 | River Ridge | NUIC West 2nd Team |
| Brady Cox | 2019 | Warren/Stockton | NUIC West Honorable Mention |
| Ethan Fye | 2019 | Lena/Winslow | NUIC West Honorable Mention |
| Braedon Fyock | 2019 | Forreston | NUIC East 1st Team (Unanimous), All-State |
| Ty Stykel | 2021 | Aquin | NUIC East 1st Team |
| Tyler Broge | 2019 | Aquin | NUIC East 1st Team |
| Chase Greenfield | 2020 | Forreston | NUIC East 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| Richie Thompson | 2020 | Dakota | NUIC East 2nd Team |
| Mitch Heinz | 2019 | Forreston | NUIC East 2nd Team |
| Brady Carlisle | 2020 | Aquin | NUIC East 2nd Team |